Old Order Amish Ivy Zook believes freedom is finally within her reach. She's wrestling with the need to shed her community's ways so she can grow the business of her dreams: planning parties. As long as she's stuck living without modernization, she can barely get her business on its feet. But if she leaves too soon, she'll cause trouble for her sister, Holly, who is planning her wedding to Joshua Smucker. All their plans become twice as complicated when an old car carrying Arlan Keim, an Amish man from the ultraconservative Swartzentruber sect, and his very ill sister, crashes into the storefront of Greene's Pharmacy. The Zooks take in Arlan and Magda, caring for brother and sister, and Arlan begins reviving their family farm even as Ivy tries to convince her mother to sell the homestead. Arlan and Ivy clash instantly, with Ivy wanting independence from her restrictive community and Arlan seeking the means to return to his. But will the warmth and joy of Christmas soften everyone's hearts to the only true freedom, the one found in Christ alone?